Ever heard of Godwin’s Law? This notion suggests that every argument, if left to fester long enough, will eventually spew forth a Hitler/Nazi/Holocaust reference. As in, “You’re just close-minded. So were the Nazis.” Taking this path is little more than a gratuitous attempt to evoke the strongest emotion conceivable, and hopefully launch that emotion in the direction of one’s argumentative stance.
The other day, I was listening to one of my favorite radio preachers. Normally, this unnamed individual presents sound, relevant correlations between everyday life and Biblical truth. On this day, however, the lesson devolved into a series of Godwin-esque cheap pleas for my emotional reactions. Allow me to recap…
Starting with a “rally cry” to turn the Iraq War into a catalyst for revival (“This war won’t be won with M-16’s, but with John 3:16!”), we were given a glimpse of a Christian faith that rides the high peaks, then…well, that’s about as far as it gets. Right on cue, we moved right on to 9/11 (whose death toll, by the way, totaled just a fraction of any one of the many hurricanes that walloped Central American in the late 90s, but most people don’t remember those). With flags in my sights and Lee Greenwood ringing in my ears, I proceeded to hear the internet-fueled tale of the steel girders from one fallen tower, which rested in the form of a cross. Then, oh and then, we had the long-awaited evoking of Godwin’s Law (I yelled “Godwin’s Law!” in my car, but I don’t think they heard me, because the story continued). I think there might have been a JFK assassination reference in there, as well as a Katrina callback, too.
Here’s where all this was going: all of these things were meant to bring about in me some understanding of the gravity of Jesus’ Second Coming. The prophecies laid out in Scripture (another talk for another day) all point to a day in the future when things will be about as bad as they can get, and then Christ will return to Earth to either (depending on your eschatology) end the bad 1,000 years or get professing believers out before the bad stuff begins.
Now, I make no bones about my walk with Christ, and that I believe the Bible to be the true Word of God. This, of course, means that, while I have no ability to understand this, I do believe that I will spend eternity in the presence of God. But I just get really uncomfortable when Biblical teachers play this card right off the bat. Perhaps it’s the notion of emotionally manipulating someone into a profession of faith in Christ, that doesn’t sit well with me. While I understand the critical nature of understanding judgment and God’s wrath, I see way too many people using them as a means of avoiding the here-and-now. Why get into the nitty-gritty of a daily walk with God, when I can just scare you into believing what I do? As any educator knows, fear of consequences is never a consistent catalyst for change in behavior.
Before you label me a cynic or a fascist (Godwin’s law!), I truly understand, as best I am able, the gravity and tragedy of the Iraq War, 9/11, and WWII. And, as a follower of Christ, I try to levy the consequences of defying God’s grace in my daily choices, as well as looking forward to the joys of Heaven. But, please, let’s just give a rest to the overdone, way-too-easy, tear-evoking references to those 5-6 huge events in history that we all have strong feelings towards. Because, if we don’t, the terrorists have already won.